Neanderthals hunted and butchered large elephants

Join CNN’s Marvel Idea science publication. Discover the universe with information on fascinating discoveries, scientific developments and extra.


Some 125,000 years in the past, huge elephants that weighed as a lot as eight vehicles every roamed in what’s now northern Europe.

Scientifically often called Palaeoloxodon antiquus, the towering animals had been the most important land mammals of the Pleistocene, standing greater than 13 ft (4 meters) excessive. Regardless of this imposing measurement, the now-extinct straight-tusked elephants had been routinely hunted and systematically butchered for his or her meat by Neanderthals, in response to a brand new research of the stays of 70 of the animals discovered at a website in central Germany often called Neumark-Nord, close to the town of Halle.

The invention is shaking up what we learn about how the extinct hominins, who existed for greater than 300,000 years earlier than disappearing about 40,000 years in the past, organized their lives. Neanderthals had been extraordinarily expert hunters, knew how you can protect meat and lived a extra settled existence in teams that had been bigger than many students had envisaged, the analysis has advised.

A definite sample of repetitive reduce marks on the floor of the well-preserved bones — the identical place on totally different animals and on the left and proper skeletal elements of a person animal — revealed that the large elephants had been dismembered for his or her meat, fats and brains after loss of life, following a kind of commonplace process over a interval of about 2,000 years. Given a single grownup male animal weighed 13 metric tons (twice as a lot as an African elephant), the butchering course of probably concerned numerous individuals and took days to finish.

Stone instruments have been present in northern Europe with different straight-tusked elephant stays that had some reduce marks. Nonetheless, scientists have by no means had readability on whether or not early people actively hunted elephants or scavenged meat from people who died of pure causes. The sheer variety of elephant bones with the systematic sample of reduce marks put this debate to relaxation, stated the authors of the research printed Wednesday within the journal Science Advances.

The Neanderthals probably used thrusting and throwing spears, which have been discovered at one other website in Germany, to focus on male elephants due to their bigger measurement and solitary habits, stated research coauthor Wil Roebroeks, a professor of Paleolithic archaeology at Leiden College in Germany. The demographics of the positioning skewed towards older and male elephants than could be anticipated had the animals died naturally, in response to the research.

“It’s a matter of immobilizing these animals or driving them into muddy shores in order that their weight works towards them,” he stated. “Should you can immobilize one with a number of individuals and nook them into an space the place they get caught. It’s a matter of ending them off.”

Study author Sabine Gaudzinski-Windheuser examining the femur of a large adult male elephant for the presence of cut marks.

What was most startling concerning the discovery was not that Neanderthals had been able to looking such massive animals however that they knew what to do with the meat, stated Britt M. Starkovich, a researcher on the Senckenberg Centre for Human Evolution and Palaeoenvironment on the College of Tübingen in Germany, in commentary printed alongside the research.

“The yield is mindboggling: greater than 2,500 each day parts of 4,000 energy per portion. A bunch of 25 foragers might thus eat a straight-tusked elephant for 3 months, 100 foragers might eat for a month, and 350 individuals might eat for every week,” wrote Starkovich, who was not concerned within the analysis.

“Neanderthals knew what they had been doing. They knew which varieties of people to hunt, the place to seek out them, and how you can execute the assault. Critically, they knew what to anticipate with a large butchery effort and a fair bigger meat return.”

The Neanderthals residing there probably knew how you can protect and retailer meat, maybe via using hearth and smoke, Roebroeks stated. It’s additionally potential that such a meat bonanza was a possibility for short-term gatherings of individuals from a bigger social community, stated research coauthor Sabine Gaudzinski-Windheuser, a professor of prehistoric and protohistoric archaeology on the Johannes Gutenberg-College in Mainz, Germany.

She defined the event might maybe have served as a wedding market. An October 2022 research primarily based on historical DNA from a small group of Neanderthals residing in what’s now Siberia advised that ladies married exterior their very own group, famous Gaudzinski-Windheuser, who can be director of the Monrepos Archaeological Analysis Centre and Museum of Human Behavioural Evolution in Neuwied.

“We don’t see that within the archaeological file however I believe the actual advantage of this research is that now all the things’s on the desk,” she stated.

Cut marks on the elephant bones, which belonged to around 70 individuals, were systematic.

Scientists had lengthy thought that Neanderthals had been extremely cell and lived in small teams of 20 or much less. Nonetheless, this newest discovering advised that they might have lived in a lot larger teams and been extra sedentary at this specific place and time, when meals was plentiful and the local weather benign. The local weather on the time — earlier than the ice sheets superior at the beginning of the final ice age round 100,000 to 25,000 years in the past — would have been just like at this time’s situations.

Killing a tusked elephant wouldn’t have been an on a regular basis occasion, the research discovered, with roughly one animal killed each 5 to 6 years at this location primarily based on the quantity discovered. It’s potential, nevertheless, that extra elephant stays had been destroyed as the positioning is a part of a open forged mine, in response to the researchers. Different finds on the website advised Neanderthals hunted a wide selection of animals throughout a lake panorama populated by wild horses, fallow deer and pink deer.

Extra broadly, the research underscores the truth that Neanderthals weren’t brutish cave dwellers so typically depicted in widespread tradition. In actual fact, the alternative is true: They had been expert hunters, understood how you can course of and protect meals, and thrived in quite a lot of totally different ecosystems and climates. Neanderthals additionally made refined instruments, yarn and artwork, and so they buried their useless with care.

“To the extra recognizably human traits that we all know Neanderthals had — taking good care of the sick, burying their useless, and occasional symbolic illustration — we now additionally want to think about that that they had preservation applied sciences to retailer meals and had been often semi sedentary or that they generally operated in teams bigger than we ever imagined,” Starkovich stated.

Leave a Comment