The Amy Winehouse biopic is making everybody very offended, however why? Dissecting the controversy round Again to Black

Although the official plot synopsis given by Taylor-Wooden in an announcement saying its go-ahead says the movie will cowl “Amy’s superbly distinctive and tragic story to cinema accompanied by an important a part of her legacy – her music”, the primary issues we’re seeing from set being public spats between Winehouse and Civil-Fielder aren’t actually serving to to appease naysayers. 

Wrapped up in overarching issues over whether or not the movie will shed new mild on the troubled actuality of Winehouse is the revelation that Abela has needed to drop pounds for the function. Chatting with the Earlier than the Lights podcast, she mentioned “I nearly see my physique as a real instrument that I’m coaching for a job”. In her defence, she additionally talked about how a lot musical, vocal and voice coaching was additionally going into making ready for the function, however the give attention to Amy’s physique, which was the results of a little-explored consuming dysfunction, has left a foul style. 

It is a delicate line for Abela to stroll. It was by no means going to be a straightforward experience taking up the life of somebody so ubiquitous to popular culture, particularly proper out of the gate as a contemporary actress. Austin Butler would possibly truthfully be the one one to have towed that line appropriately – and even then he is in all probability caught speaking like Elvis for the remainder of his life now. Even with Business underneath her belt, Abela is a comparatively new face, which might be best for casting administrators seeking to rent somebody who will not distract from the function, however arguably not a fantastic factor for Abela having to shoulder the mountain of expectations that include Amy Winehouse. 

Taylor-Wooden’s involvement within the movie has, undeniably, additionally lent a adverse lens to the manufacturing from the off. Although her work as a director greater than speaks for itself, she’s picked up criticism through the years for her relationship with husband Aaron Taylor-Johnson, who’s greater than 20 years her junior and who she met whereas he was 17 and the star Nowhere Boy. The web likes to choose a villain of the week, and effervescent underneath the floor for some time has been Taylor-Johnson. It is nearly been a trigger célèbre for a loud few who firmly get the ick from their relationship. You would in all probability make the argument that, had a distinct director been hooked up, there would not have been as a lot starvation to choose it aside to the bone.

However one of many greatest elephants within the room, and truthfully in all probability the most important trigger for concern, is the involvement of Winehouse’s personal property, particularly Mitch Winehouse. Estates being concerned is not new; the remainder of Queen had a heavy hand in Bohemian Rhapsody whereas the Presleys gave their blessing for Elvis. However Mitch Winehouse hasn’t precisely been a beacon of defending his daughter’s integrity (lest we neglect the ill-fated hologram tour that he claimed can be “an opportunity to point out the actual Amy, by hologram”). Large yikes. Amy, the 2015 documentary arguably giving one of the crucial nuanced examinations of the singer, was criticised by Mitch for portraying him as an enabler in her dependancy. Can a movie underneath the affect of somebody attempting to whitewash their very own picture ever really be dependable? 

Again to Black possible will not hit cinemas till 2024, so fears about its deserves as a delicate portrayal of Amy Winehouse lwon’t be dispelled any time quickly. Till then, so long as on-set footage hold coming our method, the Twitter ratio will in all probability hold rising. 

Leave a Comment